“Natural Republicans” As Democrats

I was in a discussion just the other day with some Chinese-immigrant friends, who raised the question, “Why do so many Chinese-Americans, who are ‘natural Republicans’, vote Democratic?” Timely question, as it is one on which the New York Times has weighed in today. Not surprisingly in light of the Times‘ recent endorsement of Hillary Clinton, the article blames things on Donald Trump, for at least exacerbating if not causing an exodus of Asian-Americans from the Republican Party.

Needless to say, one of the major problems of the article is that it treats Asian-Americans as a monolithic group, which is hardly the case. Filipinos have always been a largely Democratic group, for example.

And even for the Chinese, the group I’ll discuss here, the article oversimplifies the situation, portraying them as fervently anti-communist. That was true for many of the immigrants from Taiwan in the 1970s and 1980s, but most people coming from China today don’t have that view. Today, by the way, happens to be China’s National Day, the anniversary of the founding of the PRC, and many Chinese immigrants will be enjoying celebrations broadcast on Chinese-language television, CCTV.

But yes, in many ways, Chinese-Americans are natural Republicans. They tend to be fiscally conservative, suspicious of social engineering, and for limited government. So why are so many of them Democrats? I’ll focus for now on the immigrants, naturalized citizens.

First of all, they are not so Republican-ish as one might think. They support giving welfare benefits to elderly immigrants; they support Minority Business programs, in which city governments give minorities preference in awarding contracts; they support giving minorities preference in cabinet appointments and the like; they support the notion of the government as having a strong role in guiding the economy; etc.

The left-wing political activists in U.S. Chinatowns have deftly exploited this, and they have largely been the cause of the shift of the Chinese community from Republican to Democratic. You might wonder, “How can some progressive activists in blue-collar Chinatowns affect the views of suburban Chinese engineers?” The answer is that the Chinatown activists have major access to the Chinese-language media, both electronic and print.

And the biggest issue the activists have been able to exploit is welfare. The issue of welfare benefits for elderly immigrants — cash, medical care, senior housing and so on for people who typically have never worked in the U.S. — has played an absolutely pivotal role in making many Chinese Democrats. This was a big issue in Congress in the early- and mid-1990s, culminating in the Welfare Reform Act of 1996, some provisions of which barred green card holders from access to federal benefits. (They could access the benefits only by naturalizing.) It is important to note that this was a bipartisan action. The Democrats took the lead in 1993, tightening up on immigrant access to welfare by lengthening the waiting period from three years in the U.S. to five. The 1996 bill was Republican-sponsored, but it was signed by Democratic president Bill Clinton, and even the Democrats’ competing bill had also placed restrictions on the immigrants.

But in spite of the bipartisan nature of the restrictions, the Chinatown activists then portrayed this as “The Republicans took away our welfare,” which became a huge motivator for Chinese to become Dems. People like Yvonne Lee, a member of the U.S. Civil Rights Commission and the Chinese activists’ direct line to the White House, presented the matter as one in which Clinton “reluctantly” accepted the immigrant provisions in the bill. This was at best a half-truth, since as I said there was a bipartisan consensus that immigrant usage of welfare had gotten way out of hand, but the Chinese-language media presented the Republicans as the culprits.

This created its own momentum. There are many Chinese-Americans today who are unaware of this history (as are many DC insiders, for that matter), but become Democrats after hearing a pro-Democratic drumbeat in the community that had its roots in the 1990s.

What about the “ABCs” — American-born Chinese? They of course tend to be more liberal than their parents — they are far more supportive of Affirmative Action programs than are their parents, for instance — so they are “natural Democrats.”

Concerning Trump, contrary to the claim made in the article, I very much doubt that many Chinese-Americans are put off by his tough stance on China trade. I do believe that many dislike some of his antics, which they may consider undignified. But there are certainly many Chinese Trump supporters, even among Democrats, I find. And they support him for the same reason that other Americans do: They believe the government has lost touch with the people.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on ““Natural Republicans” As Democrats

  1. On the con side, this reflects what I have found with many H1Bs – a “Kill the golden goose” attitude toward any benefit, private or public. “One for one and none for all” seem to be their mantra. In the next decade, when the US finally has to face its $20 Trillion current and $200 Trillion future deficits and the ponzi welfare schemes are scaled back or go bankrupt, it will be interesting to see if the immigrants stay here or head back to their home countries.

    An Indian co-worker, during a discussion on the environment, said they don’t have such concerns back home. Any resource is quickly used up by the first group to grab it. The 3rd World corruption accelerates the effort with the many large-scale pollution problems of China and India illustrating the results. I also think we will see more Eastern versions of Tammany Hall with more Leland Yee type scandals in the coming years:

    http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-leland-yee-q-and-a-20160223-story.html

    On the pro side, when immigrants start business, they usually become more conservative if not Republicans over a period of time. When they see the effects of welfare on their “non-productive” neighbors and the ever increasing taxes that they have to pay, the Democrat platform doesn’t seem as attractive. During my last visits to gun shows and firing ranges, I encountered more minorities of all types – East Asians, Blacks, Hispanics, Middle Eastern, South Asians, etc. They’re support will be needed if we are going to keep our 2nd Amendment and self-protection rights.

    Like

    • Yes, lots of minorities, native and immigrant alike, are gun owners.

      Concerning “One for one and none for all,” I describe it as “Su casa es mi casa, mi casa es mi casa.” 🙂 But this is the culture they grew up in, what can we say?

      Like

  2. Many (most?) Chinese-Americans support affirmative action even though no racial or ethnic group is harmed more by affirmative action than Chinese-Americans. Go figure.

    Like

    • As a supporter of affirmative action myself, I am biased here, but I would point out that Chinese-Americans benefit from affirmative action in the ways I cited, e.g. preference in Minority Business contracts, which they pursue quite vigorously.

      Like

      • I am tired of hyphenated Americans. How can we become a colorblind society when groups choose to self segregate or claim privileges based on race and ethnicity?

        Like

  3. I worked on the Santa Clara light rail project for a small Chinese-American owned firm. People said that because the big engineering companies like Bechtel that got the major contracts were mostly white, the small sub-contractors were essentially all minority-owned [or by other government-preferred groups like veterans] – white-owned firms wouldn’t even bid. The two owners of my company, born in China, were very sharp. It seemed to me that, based on success around the world, Chinese were not really in need of preference in business generally, but that’s the system.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s